13 Jul 2015 19:34:22
Bastian, an excellent punt at the price and although age and injuries will make it difficult to hit previous brilliance still has plenty to offer at the top. Been there done it difficult to imagine not being a success. My view he will be a hit
Stirling, not keen on the bloke but as a young player he's already shown he can shine brightly in a title challenging team, can't imagine he will be any less effective for city than he was at Liverpool the season before last. For me will be a hit too.
Spyder for me is much like Carvalho been good in a very decent side but can he shine in a side chasing a title in the world's most competitive league? Worth a punt no question but the fact is dispite waiting and waiting no one other offers came in other than utds. For me 50/50 to make the grade at the very top.
Cech? Very few players come with the odds so high in their favour of being anything other than a success. Hard to imagine him being anything but a massive Hit

1.) 13 Jul 2015
13 Jul 2015 20:18:09
I Gunner,

I pretty much agree with everything you've said there mate, except I would imagine Spyder to less of a gamble than Carvalho, simply because he's stood out against the top 4 sides and he knows the league well.

As you say though, we'll only tell once theses players get going.

I actually slightly disagree with Cech too, while I agree he will be incredible for you, much like BS, age (and a lack of football for a year) will likely see a slight decline but nothing which will stop him from being a success.

Personally I think so far, having spent £75M, United have completed the best business, Depay, MS and BS are 3 very good signings in my opinion.